Why your content isn’t resonating (and how to fix it)

Here’s the brutal truth most founders don’t want to hear…

If your content isn’t converting into clients:

❌ It’s not your offer.
❌ It’s not your pricing.
❌ And no, it’s not the algorithm.

It’s that your audience doesn’t know why you exist.

If they don’t know why you exist, they don’t care that you do.

And if you don’t fix that?

You’ll keep getting ignored no matter how brilliant your offer is.

I’ve seen this over and over: smart, capable founders shouting into the void, wondering why their posts don’t convert and their inbox stays quiet.

The missing piece?

Your origin story.

Not just any story.

The one that makes your audience feel like, “Holy sh*t… this person gets me.”

Most founders get storytelling wrong.
When I first started trying to build trust online, I did what everyone else was doing:
✅ Tip posts
✅ Tool lists
✅ Endless “value drops”

But instead of building connection, I got hit with comments like:

“How do I know this even works?”

or worse

“Another fake guru.”

That stung. Because they weren’t wrong.

All the valuable info in the world won’t build trust unless your story gives it weight.

That’s when I found Russell Brunson’s “Expert Secrets.”

In it, he talks about something called the “Epiphany Bridge” story (which is essentially his version of Joseph Campbell’s Hero’s Journey).

The Epiphany Bridge story is your offer’s origin story. Similar to a superhero origin story, this brand story shows the transformation from the metaphorical scrawny nerd to the muscular, flying hero.

This Epiphany Bridge story is the crucial backstory your audience needs to relate, sympathize, and ultimately trust you.

Aka, it’s how you go from “just another expert” to the one your audience wants to work with.

So, what I learned is: facts don’t build trust. Stories do.

And if you’re not intentionally crafting your story, the market will do it for you (and spoiler: they’ll get it wrong).

So I stopped hiding behind bullet points and started sharing my Brand Story.

  • The failures.
  • The pivots.
  • The why behind my method.

After that? Everything changed.

My content was no longer blending in with the sea of AI-generated posts.

My audience was connecting with my words. Relating to my stories. And engaging on my posts.

I began earning the trust I needed to start winning not just hearts, but minds and wallets too.

So, what’s this framework?

Let’s get into it…

The 4-Part Framework That Sells Without Selling

Over time I refined the Epiphany Bridge into a simple, easy-to-remember structure I now teach inside my Personal Brand Accelerator.

It’s called The 4 Bs, and it’s the DNA of a story that builds emotional connection and converts.

Here’s the breakdown:

1. BEFORE: Show Them You Were Once Like Them

This is your “ordinary world.” The moment before it all changed.

Think of it as the pre-movie montage – the life you lived before your transformation.

It’s where your audience sees themselves in your shoes and starts thinking, “Wait, this person gets it.”

Why it matters:

People don’t trust experts who feel out of reach. They trust those who’ve walked their path and made it out the other side.

How to find it:

Ask yourself:

  • What pain or confusion were you sitting in before you found your method?
  • What beliefs or bad advice were you following?
  • What did life or business feel like in that phase?

How to use it:

Don’t just list struggles. Describe the emotional texture of that time. This is the moment where you say: “I was you. And here’s what that looked like.”

2. BREAKDOWN: Show Them You Felt Their Pain

This is the moment everything cracked open.

It’s not just about struggle. It’s the turning point. The catalyst. The “I can’t do this anymore” moment that sets the rest of the story in motion.

Why it matters:

Transformation doesn’t start with information. It starts with frustration.

If your audience doesn’t feel the urgency, they won’t follow you to the solution.

How to find it:

Ask yourself:

  • What made you snap?
  • What realization hit you like a ton of bricks?
  • What failure or frustration pushed you to seek a new way?

How to use it:

Don’t over-polish this part. Make it raw. Make it real. This is where your audience needs to feel your pain because it mirrors theirs.

3. BUILD: Show Them You Earned Your Solution

This is the messy middle. The late nights, false starts, bad advice, and slow wins that eventually led to your breakthrough.

It’s the grit phase that too many people skip in their content (and that’s exactly why it builds trust).

Why it matters:

No one believes in overnight success. They believe in earned success. The build shows them you didn’t stumble into results… You built them.

How to find it:

Ask yourself:

  • What frameworks or mentors helped you change?
  • What did you test, tweak, or trash?
  • How did you evolve your method or mindset?

How to use it:

Think “behind the scenes” meets “teaching moment.” This is where you show your process and prove you didn’t just Google your way to results.

4. BRAND: Show Them the Bigger Mission

This is your transformation. Not just how you changed, but how your work now helps others do the same.

It’s where your personal story becomes a movement.

Why it matters:

People don’t buy products. They join missions. If they can see how your values, vision, and voice align with theirs, they’ll follow you far beyond the first sale.

How to find it:

Ask yourself:

  • What do you believe now that you didn’t before?
  • What ripple effect does your work create for your clients?
  • What bigger shift are you trying to lead?

How to use it:

This is where you cast the vision. Show them that working with you isn’t just about fixing a pain point, it’s about becoming part of something bigger.

This is how you create story-driven trust—not just attention.

  • Before shows reliability.
  • Breakdown shows empathy.
  • Build shows proof.
  • Brand shows mission.

If you want a story that sells without sounding salesy, this is how you do it.

And if you want help crafting your Brand Story in less than 15 minutes… I got you!

I’ve bundled everything I teach into a free tool called the Brand Origin Story Generator (GPT).

👉 Grab the free Brand Story Generator here 👈

It walks you through the 4 Bs step by step and spits out a full draft of your personal brand story in under 15 minutes.

✔️ Social content
✔️ Sales deck
✔️ About page
✔️ Wherever trust needs to happen fast

It’s fast, simple, and frankly… the critical story your brand has been missing.

Because here’s the thing:

Your story isn’t fluff.

It’s not a “nice to have.”

It’s your sales strategy.

The brands that last are the ones that make their audience feel something first.

👉 Grab the free Brand Story Generator here 👈

Craft your story.

Scale your trust.

Build your movement.

See you on the inside, 🤜🤛

Dave

Whenever you’re ready, there are 4 ways I can help you:

1. Connect with me on LinkedIn for actionable content strategies.

2. ​Download my Solopreneur’s Toolbox for apps and gear to grow your solo business.

3. Book a 1:1 content strategy consultation to see how we can work together.

4. Get started with your custom personal brand transformation.

Not a Subscriber?

Get my latest content strategies in your inbox each week.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Share this article on:

Join the Community

I don’t spam. Unsubscribe anytime.